Skip to content
Philo Spot
  • Home
  • About Philospot
  • Support

Philo Spot

Life Interests and Observations

Tag: Atheist

Why I am an Atheist

March 29, 2019 by Douglas Jimenez

What is the state of belief of an atheist? An atheist is often defined as someone who does not believe in God. It is quite true that an atheist does not believe in God, but that is insufficient to define the state of belief of an atheist. A tree or a rock or a lizard does not believe in God either–but it would be bizarre to describe such beings as atheists. This is because they are not believers at all, in anything. And even a dog or a chimpanzee, which plausibly do have beliefs, are hardly to be characterized as atheists. Furthermore, an agnostic does not believe in God either, since he suspends belief on the question. What is missing, obviously, is the fact that an atheist disbelieves in the existence of God—he believes that there is no God. He doesn’t merely lack belief in a divinity; he positively believes in the absence of a divinity. Moreover, he takes his negative belief to be rational, to be backed by reasons. He doesn’t just find himself with a belief that there is no God; he comes to that belief by what he takes to be rational means—that is, he takes his belief to be justified. He may not regard his atheistic belief as certain, but he certainly takes it to be reasonable—as reasonable as any belief he holds. Just by holding the belief he regards himself as rationally entitled to it (or else he wouldn’t, as a responsible believer, believe it—that being the nature of belief). Also, given the nature of belief, he takes himself to know that there is no God: for to believe that p is to take oneself to know that p. The atheist, like any believer in a proposition, regards his belief as an instance of knowledge (of course, it may not be, but he necessarily takes is to be so). So an atheist is someone who thinks he knows there is no God. Thus he is prepared responsibly to assert that there is no God. The atheist regards himself as knowing there is no God in just the sense that he regards himself as knowing, say, that the earth is round. He claims to know the objective truth about the universe in respect of a divinity—that the universe contains no such entity. Of course, this entails that he claims to know that other people’s beliefs on this question are false, i.e. the theists who believe that there is a God. He also claims to know that the agnostics are mistaken too: they suspend belief when it is rational to commit oneself on the question. If an agnostic asserts that only a state of non-belief about the existence of God is rational, the atheist takes the view that this is false: it is rational to hold positively that there is no God, not merely to be neutral on the question. The atheist thus claims to know that theists and agnostics are epistemically defective—that they have false and unwarranted beliefs about the question of God’s existence. He then has reason to wish to alter their beliefs so as to bring them into line with the truth. True beliefs are better than false ones, and he has the true beliefs while theirs are false.

It would be quite wrong, then, to describe an atheist as a “non-believer”. He does not merely lack beliefs; he has many beliefs, among them that there is no God. It is not that the atheist is somehow shy of belief or afflicted with pathologically high standards for belief formation; he is not a skeptic, …

Continue Reading

Random Posts

  • Relativism and Democracy
  • How to prepare for freedivingHow to prepare for freediving
  • Some Basic Facts
  • Strictly Said
  • Reply to Letter
  • How to put together a survival kitHow to put together a survival kit
  • 7 Tips For Playing Golf In Winter7 Tips For Playing Golf In Winter
  • The Prehensionalist Manifesto
  • Morality, Reported Speech, and ”Hand Job”: A Refutation
  • The Genius Project

Recent posts

  • How to put together a survival kit
  • How to prepare for freediving
  • 7 Tips For Playing Golf In Winter

Categories

  • Atheist
  • Eparter les bourgeios
  • General
  • Hand Job
  • Letter
  • Philospot
  • Project

Site Pages

  • Home
  • About Philospot
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Support
© 2021 Philo Spot | WordPress Theme by Superbthemes